Skip to main content

Kuddelmuddel

As soon as the newbie lawyer reaches the valley, he facetiously remarks, "wahan sirf terrorists marte hain, army wale nahi? ". This line is what the writers of shaurya must defend. The reason why an age-old movie makes a mention today is to signify how crudely "Aman ki Asha" was shoved down the throat of millions of unsuspecting Indians. Morarji Desai was given Nishan-e-Pakistan for his contributions to the State of Pakistan, including sabotaging the RAW mission to extract and prevent the nuclear program in Pakistan. The second person who was this close to the Pakistani establishment has to A. S. Daulat. One who was said to know everything about Kashmir, but instead of working out a solution, he kept the status quo, enjoying a leveraged position from the government and the separatists of the valley, selling a dream of peace which kept his coffers filling. 

At this time, India wanted to make a case for its pacifism, showing the west it was a follower of the Gandhian dogma to be slapped in both faces instead of one. One that Shaurya tries to portray with the character of Siddhant Choudary (Rahul Bose)

shows a progressive, free-spirited approach that clashes with Major Pratap (Kay Kay Menon). Sid feels deeply about his father's heroism as a personal loss; he dislikes that people don't love the army as they do their pets. To an extent, Sid so detests the military that you would beg him to quit his job. 

But that's only where some troubles with the narrative start. A lead actress is a media person with whom Sid develops a bond and confides in his deepest fears. This goes on to explain how the Indians were made to believe that the media somehow was a more empathetic companion to international happens than the army. Although none in the military (I can vouch on that even from my experience in the cadet corps) with ever entertain such an idea, when the country and sacrifice of thousands of army men are in question, none of the media houses which thrive on TRP and NGO funds are to be believed. This premise is not foreign to Indians, who have seen prominent media figures leak key army locations, which were ultimately military disasters, however, the government kept showering laurels on them. 

To credit where it's due, the movie does present a case for the potential misuse of power and ordnance in places of continuous military action, often with a bias and prejudice that stems from personal reasons. And that would demand officers be diligent and mindful of their orders. But this should be no excuse for indiscipline. Instead, in the true army spirit, what better serves the country is the proper duty of a soldier. 

Popular posts from this blog

Politics of Perpetuity

There are obvious downsides to democracy. When we look at the distribution of opinion on a particular issue, it generally follows a normal distribution. This implies that to achieve the majority, it's theoretically advised to stick to the centre. And this love for mediocrity makes democracy allergic to politically solid decisions.  Along with it, democracies tend to be the rooster for sweet talkers. And that is an outcome rather than a voluntary trait. Primarily because most voters need to be equipped to deal with the complexities of the field. For example, it could be more practical for an electrical engineer to comprehend medical patterns and the pandemic's effect on production. Thus, democratic institutions need people managers who have two keywords to watch out for - sweet talking and status quo. However, democracies have been hugely popular. And people have reported being happier. Whether this is induced, indoctrinated or influenced is another question. But history has cho...
dive in...

Turning back from pull to push

Two recent campaigns deserve attention from marketing enthusiasts, one of Campa Cola (reenergised by the Reliance Group) and of Tata Sampann's species. The challenges these two brands face are too distinct from one another. Campa, on the one hand, aims to fight the global brands like Pepsi and Coca-Cola, whereas Sampann looks to create a market in indian spices that has been dominated by local players like MDH and Everest. However, their strategies have something in common: getting the distributors to stock more of their products on the shelves. Campa is offering the distributors twice the margins, while Sampann is leveraging its vast portfolio to make stocking only Tata products a win for the distributors. Image credit: Economic Times To understand why this is happening, and what makes this interesting, one has to look back on the history of marketing, more specifically the shift from a push to a pull-based marketing, where the focus of the brands shifted from pushing their produc...
dive in...

The Theatre Era

As tough times await us, it's frivolous to talk about theatres. But doesn't it look like theatres would go out of fashion before the pandemic ends( But would it ?? ) With the footfall on OTT platforms rising daily. Looking at a screen stuck to the chair, with no ability to pause or even play subtitles, sounds so technologically inferior. The blockbuster release has increasingly been  generously funded , mega-multi-starrer films, which keep running sequels until they go unprofitable . In fact, content is sometimes the second priority; the fan base and the festive season come first. Over the years, movie houses have mastered this art. Roping in top actors into characters that have gone synonymous with their name. The OTT platforms, however, are earmarked for the content. Their promise to give a shot to the aspiring director who doesn't have funds to compete against the mult-million movie releases. Thus i n its cast and crew shines the raw, untamed art which any critic would b...
dive in...