Skip to main content

What if "Maggus" don't have a choice ?

There are two possible reasons for stopping by this post; you happened to be among those hard-working study-serious college-goer who lament not being perceived as fun by his/her peers. Or you have a soft spot for these people, striving to pay off the debt from when he single-handedly completed your group project. There could be a hundred other reasons, so let's jump into the matter.

Let's construct a scenario with simplified assumptions. Suppose there are 5 students in your project team. Each of you has decided whether you want to work or not. If you decide to work, you must put in an effort of value "e". The project will be possible if at least 3 of the students participate. A successful project rewards everyone in the team "r", which is greater in value than "e". So what do you think will happen.
Let's assume that each of you is rational (which secretly implies you will maximise your personal gain whenever possible). Will all five contribute ?? Will no one work?? Is there another situation??
  • Will all of the five work?
Let's assume they do. But each of them realised that they put in more effort than required. And this information is available to all of them. In fact, two of them can slack and still get the reward "r". This is a better scenario for them since r > r - e. So the next time they work, all five may slack.
  • When no one works.
In this case, no or works, and there is no reward. In fact, there is no incentive for anyone to start working even since he/she can't single-handedly complete the project. So wasting that effort e needs to make sense.
  • Wait, what if just 3 of them worked?
And lo, here we have three (let's call them maggus) who decided to pull off the task. The whole group gets the reward. But will the non-working members start working? Well, no. They have a reward r and have no incentive to spend that effort e because that will reduce their gain to r - e
Can the maggus stop working? Well, no. they have a reward r - e.  If they stop working, the project will fail, reducing their net gains to 0. This is a Nash equilibrium. A point where no player can take an action that maximises his personal gain.

In fact, this is of serious consequence to public goods, notably called the free-riders problem. But what remains extremely important to conclude from this example, is there are some maggus who know they are stuck in a group that can't let them be otherwise. Just like I can't stop writing "in fact"s.

Popular posts from this blog

Politics of Perpetuity

There are obvious downsides to democracy. When we look at the distribution of opinion on a particular issue, it generally follows a normal distribution. This implies that to achieve the majority, it's theoretically advised to stick to the centre. And this love for mediocrity makes democracy allergic to politically solid decisions.  Along with it, democracies tend to be the rooster for sweet talkers. And that is an outcome rather than a voluntary trait. Primarily because most voters need to be equipped to deal with the complexities of the field. For example, it could be more practical for an electrical engineer to comprehend medical patterns and the pandemic's effect on production. Thus, democratic institutions need people managers who have two keywords to watch out for - sweet talking and status quo. However, democracies have been hugely popular. And people have reported being happier. Whether this is induced, indoctrinated or influenced is another question. But history has cho...

Changing face of Entertainment

The entertainment industry in India is waiting for yet another disruptive innovation, with millions of young users equipped with gigabytes of data every day, there is a new untapped customer base. Not particularly untapped since it makes do with pirated movies and free web series. But, there is an apparent lack of entertainment streamed towards them. Also, the shift from television sets to mobile devices, sets the stage clear for a change in content. the spikes in porn consumption and adult web series do speak of this unattended guest. The popularity of two platforms, mostly youtube and TikTok, have also helped in developing a new class of actors. To name a few Sumeet Vyas, Jitendra, Bhuvan Bam and much more. It has become apparent that the arduous task of going from one to another production house seeking a side role in a daily soap or movie, is on a decline. Not that, people won't get their debut at soaps and movies, but it seems easier to get a web series and keep working tha...